May 2017 Comment Resolution on EDMG A-PPDU Structure

May 2017 Comment Resolution on EDMG A-PPDU Structure
Slide Note
Embed
Share

This document discusses proposed changes and resolutions related to the A-PPDU structure in the context of EDMG. It addresses ambiguities in the specification and proposes adjustments to ensure compatibility with different Guard Interval (GI) settings.

  • IEEE 802.11
  • Resolution
  • A-PPDU Structure
  • EDMG
  • Guard Interval
bona_byl
bona_byl Follow

Uploaded on Apr 19, 2025 | 0 Views

Download Presentation

Please find below an Image/Link to download the presentation.

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.If you encounter any issues during the download, it is possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

You are allowed to download the files provided on this website for personal or commercial use, subject to the condition that they are used lawfully. All files are the property of their respective owners.

Download Presentation

The content on the website is provided AS IS for your information and personal use only. It may not be sold, licensed, or shared on other websites without obtaining consent from the author.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. May 2017 Comment Resolution on EDMG A-PPDU Structure Date: 2017-05-10 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Authors: Name Affiliations Address Phone Email Takenori Sakamoto Panasonic Corporation 600 Saedo-cho, Tsuzuki-ku, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan sakamoto.takenori@jp.panasonic.com Hiroyuki Motozuka Panasonic Corporation Panasonic Corporation Panasonic Corporation Panasonic Corporation Panasonic Corporation motozuka.hiroyuki@jp.panasonic.com Lei Huang lei.huang@sg.panasonic.com Gaius Wee yaohuang.wee@sg.panasonic.com Yutaka Murakami murakami.ytk@jp.panasonic.com Kazu Takahashi takahashi.kazu@jp.panasonic.com Submission Slide 1 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  2. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Abstract This submission proposes resolution on CID 9. CID 9 Page 100 Line 16 Comment Proposed Change Add A-PPDU structure details including the GIs, headers, etc like is provides for the single PPDU case in section 30.5.6.2.2 A-PPDU structures are missing detailed specification that can result in potential ambiguity in interpreting the standard Submission Slide 2 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  3. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Problem #1 Since only normal GI is specified in 11ad [1], the L-Header within the Nth PPDU within the DMG A-PPDU and the final data symbol block within the (N-1)th PPDU within the DNG A-PPDU can share the GI. On the other hand, 11ay supports short/normal/long GI [2]. The EDMG-Header-A shall be prepended by the normal GI. The data symbol blocks can be prepended by the short/normal/long GI. When using short/long GI, the EDMG-Header-A within the Nth PPDU and the final data symbol block within the (N-1)th PPDU can not share the GI because of no cyclicity as shown below. PPDU #N-1 PPDU #N DATA DATA DATA Header-A1 Header-A2 DATA GIei32*NCB GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB 64* NCB 32* NCB Short GI Short GI 480*NCB 448*NCB Not cyclic Not cyclic GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB 64* NCB 64* NCB Normal GI Normal GI 448*NCB 448*NCB Cyclic Cyclic GIei128*NCB GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB NCB 64* 64* NCB Long GI Long GI 128*NCB 384*NCB 448*NCB Not cyclic Not cyclic Submission Slide 3 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  4. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Proposal Not only the final symbol block within the last PPDU within the EDMG SC A-PPDU but also the final symbol block of the all PPDUs within the EDMG SC A-PPDU shall be followed by the same GI regardless on the value of the Additional EDMG PPDU field within the corresponding EDMG-Header-A. PPDU #N-1 PPDU #N DATA DATA DATA Header-A1 Header-A2 DATA GIei32*NCB GIei32*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB 64* NCB 32* NCB 32* NCB Short GI Short GI 480*NCB 448*NCB GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB 64* NCB 64* NCB 64* NCB Normal GI Normal GI 448*NCB 448*NCB GIei128*NCB GIei128*NCB GIei64*NCB DATA EDMG-Header-A1 64* NCB 64* NCB Long GI Long GI 128*NCB 384*NCB 128*NCB 448*NCB Submission Slide 4 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  5. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Problem #2 The PPDU structure for the jth PPDU (1 j N) within the EDMG SC A-PPDU is different from any other type of SU PPDU structures specified in [2]. The non-EDMG portion, the EDMG-STF and the EDMG-CEF shall not be transmitted in the jth PPDU (1 j N). We need to specify new PPDU structure for the jth PPDU (1 j N) within the EDMG SC A-PPDU. Submission Slide 5 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  6. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Proposal For j = 0: The 1st PPDU structure shall be the same as the SU PPDU structures specified in [2]. For 1 j N: The similar PPDU structure of the MU PPDU specified in [2] can be applied to the jth PPDU within the EDMG A-PPDU. The only difference is that not EDMG-Header-B but EDMG-Header-A is transmitted. The EDMG-Header-A and the 1st data block are prepended by GIei64*NCB when the short GI or normal GI is used. The EDMG-Header-A is prepended by GIei128*NCB[1:64*NCB] and the 1st data block is prepended by GIei128*NCB when the long GI is used. GIei GIei GIei GIei GIei GIei DATA DATA DATA 64*NCB 64*NCB 64*NCB 32*NCB 32*NCB 32*NCB 32 32* * NC NC B B 32 32* * NC NC B B 32 32* * NC NC B B 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB Short GI 480*NCB 480*NCB . . . 480*NCB EDMG-Header-A1 EDMG-Header-A2 GIei GIei GIei GIei GIei GIei DATA DATA DATA 64*NCB 64*NCB 64*NCB 64*NCB 64*NCB 64*NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB Normal GI 448*NCB 448*NCB . . . 448*NCB EDMG-Header-A1 EDMG-Header-A2 GIei [1:64*NCB] GIei [1:64*NCB] GIei GIei GIei GIei 128*NCB 128*NCB DATA DATA DATA 128*NCB 128*NCB 128*NCB 128*NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB 64 64* * NCB NCB Long GI 128 128* *NCB NCB 128 128* *NCB NCB 128 128* *NCB NCB 128 128* *NCB NCB 384*NCB 384*NCB . . . 384*NCB EDMG-Header-A1 EDMG-Header-A2 Submission Slide 6 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  7. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 Conclusion We propose PPDU structure for the EDMG A-PPDU. The final block of all PPDUs within the EDMG SC A-PPDU shall be followed by the same GI as data field. The similar PPDU structure to the MU PPDU structure is applied to the jth PPDU (1 j N) within the EDMG SC A-PPDU. Submission Slide 7 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

  8. May 2017 doc.: IEEE 802.11-17/0760r3 References [1] 802.11-2016 [2] Draft P802.11ay_D0.3 Submission Slide 8 Takenori Sakamoto, Panasonic Corporation

Related


Two-Dimensional A-PPDU for Low Latency in UHR Networks

Two-Dimensional A-PPDU for Low Latency in UHR Networks

asha
IEEE 802.11-20/0029r3 Preamble Structure and SIG Contents Overview

IEEE 802.11-20/0029r3 Preamble Structure and SIG Contents Overview

andy
IEEE 802.11-22/2083r1 Wake-Up Radio (WUR) and MC-OOK Signals

IEEE 802.11-22/2083r1 Wake-Up Radio (WUR) and MC-OOK Signals

granger
IEEE 802.11-20/0049r2: PPDU Types and Bandwidth Information Update

IEEE 802.11-20/0049r2: PPDU Types and Bandwidth Information Update

jasleen
Enhancing Throughput with Aggregated PPDU for Large Bandwidth IEEE 802.11 Networks

Enhancing Throughput with Aggregated PPDU for Large Bandwidth IEEE 802.11 Networks

rainey
IEEE 802.11-20/1192r0 TB PPDU Format Signaling in Trigger Frame

IEEE 802.11-20/1192r0 TB PPDU Format Signaling in Trigger Frame

darcy
Carrier PPDU Discussion for Long-range Backscatter Operation in IEEE 802.11-24

Carrier PPDU Discussion for Long-range Backscatter Operation in IEEE 802.11-24

dony_68
Discussion on IEEE 802.11-23/1865r0: SST and A-PPDU

Discussion on IEEE 802.11-23/1865r0: SST and A-PPDU

amho532
Fair Comment Defense in Scottish Law

Fair Comment Defense in Scottish Law

shae_314
Near-far Self-Classification Capabilities of EDMG STAs

Near-far Self-Classification Capabilities of EDMG STAs

core_192
Channel Estimation Field for EDMG OFDM PHY in 11ay

Channel Estimation Field for EDMG OFDM PHY in 11ay

cha_hin
Proposal for EDMG-Header-A Design Considerations

Proposal for EDMG-Header-A Design Considerations

fike_i
Resolving Deadlocks in Comment Resolution

Resolving Deadlocks in Comment Resolution

catch
Time-domain A-PPDU for Collision Reduction and Priority Access

Time-domain A-PPDU for Collision Reduction and Priority Access

car_bou
Time-domain A-PPDU for Collision Reduction and Priority Access

Time-domain A-PPDU for Collision Reduction and Priority Access

shonkwiler_s
L-Header Spoofing and Bit Reuse in IEEE 802.11-16

L-Header Spoofing and Bit Reuse in IEEE 802.11-16

holley_a
IEEE 802.11-19/1540r7 EHT Preamble Design

IEEE 802.11-19/1540r7 EHT Preamble Design

svensson_d
Evolution of IEEE 802.11 Preamble Design Philosophy

Evolution of IEEE 802.11 Preamble Design Philosophy

edush
11be PPDU format

11be PPDU format

bly_mod
Deep Learning for Low-Resolution Hyperspectral Image Classification

Deep Learning for Low-Resolution Hyperspectral Image Classification

hernandez_j
IEEE 802.11-16/0988r1 Non-EDMG Part of Preamble for MIMO in 11ay

IEEE 802.11-16/0988r1 Non-EDMG Part of Preamble for MIMO in 11ay

dessiewo
IEEE 802.11-16/0994r1 EDMG-STF and CEF Design for SC PHY in 11ay

IEEE 802.11-16/0994r1 EDMG-STF and CEF Design for SC PHY in 11ay

isabe

More Related Content