NanoElectronics Roadmap for Europe Identification and Dissemination

NEREID ICT-CSA: Micro- and Nano-Electronics Technologies Grant Agreement n 685559 Francis Balestra (francis.balestra@grenoble-inp.fr) Grenoble INP/CNRS, Coordinator of Nereid 2nd General Workshop Athens, April 6-7, 2017 Title : NanoElectronics Roadmap for Europe: Identification and Dissemination

Why a new roadmap (for Europe)? New killer applications beyond computing From computers to communications and networked applications; From Scaling and associated technologies to Enabling technologies ; European industry focusing on application driven technologies New technologies, new physical effects New, unforeseeable markets No single Figure of Merit New road mapping methodology Starting from 1) applications ,2) techno Medium and long terms Covering the full supply chain 2

Why a new roadmap for Europe (2)? -to take into account the specificity of the European industrial and academic landscape -to be used: as input for research programmes of European and national organizations to better coordinate academic and industrial research For equipment, semiconductors and application development. 3

NEREID Structure Beyond CMOS Communication & Dissemination Coordination with roadmap Advanced Logic and Connectivity Advisory Committee with high level representatives Management initiatives Functional diversification 10-15 members: Europe, USA, Asia System Design & Heterogeneous Integration Equipment & Manufacturing Science

NEREID: Tasks and Topics WP Work Package Tasks 1. 1 Administrative management (Grenoble INP) 1 Management (INP, SINANO) 1.2 Technical Management (SINANO Institute) 2.1 Emerging devices (VTT) 2 Beyond CMOS (VTT) 2.2 Computing paradigms (ICN2) 3.1 Nanoscale FET (INP) 3 Advanced Logic & Connectivity (imec) 3.2 Connectivity (LETI) 4.1 Smart sensor (EPFL) 4 Functional Diversification (LETI) 4.2 Smart Energy (IUNET) 5.1 System Design (PoliTo) 5 System Design & Heter. Integr. (PoliTo) 5.2 Heterogeneous Integration (Tyndall) 6.1 Equipment and Materials (imec) 6 Equipm. & Manufact. Science (FhG) 6.2 Manufacturing Science (FhG) 7.1 Set-up of web node and comm. Tools (ECN) Communication & Dissemination (EDAcentrum) 7 7.2 Planning of Dissemination events (ECN) Coordination with roadmap initiatives (EPFL) 8 Advisory Board

NEREID: Industrial co-Leaders Industrial co-leaders AENEAS IBM Zurich STMicroelectronics Infineon (Smart Energy) WP WP1 WP2 WP3 Description Management Beyond CMOS Advanced Logic and Connectivity WP4 Functional diversification NXP (Smart Sensors) WP5 System Design & Heterogeneous Integration Infineon ASML & ASMI (Equipments) WP6 Equipment & Manufacturing Science STMicroelectronics (Manufacturing) AENEAS WP7 Communication & Dissemination WP8 Coordination with roadmap initiatives

NEREID structure Aiming at large participation of (>100 !) experts (internal, external ; application, technology) from leading European academic and industrial institutions in Workshops Limited number of formal partners, all academic, with a clear responsibility for coordinating specific topics. Industry participates by providing experts with travel cost refund and co-leaders for Work Packages and Tasks. Industry participation through AENEAS industrial association representing European Technology Platform Nanoelectronics. 7

NEREID Roadmap flow Kick-Off WS ENF Dec. 2015 Automotive Medical Security Energy Industrial IoT Mobile convergence Task groups organization / Expert selection-Feb. 16 1stGeneral WS Application Requirements (AE+some TE) April 2016 Domain WS Domain WS Domain WS Cross-Domain WS (TE) 2ndGeneral WS Application drivers April 2017 Methodology based on ITRS 2.0, but focusing on European Nanoelectronics and Application industry From Application needs to specific technical workshops One WP and Advisory Board for coordination with other roadmap initiatives (IRDS ) Domain WS Domain WS Domain WS Cross-Domain WS Conclusive WS Roadmap finalization 2018 8

NEREID Roadmapping: 2 approaches Top-down (GW): Bottom-up (DW): Expected applications evolution vs time: Energy, Automotive, Medical/Life science, Security, IoT/Smart connected objects, Mobile convergence, Digital Manufacturing (Low power, ) Future Technologies availability vs time Which technology can satisfy the required function performance for each application, including possible gaps: refinement of analysis Which function ? Performance evolution vs time of generic function (e.g. Sensing, Computation, Communication, Energy management/harvesting) ? Additional ideas for future products and applications Needed evolution vs time of different possible underlying technologies

Medical and Life Sciences Smart Internet of things Energy Application drivers transportation (Generic) Functions: Convergence Outside system connectivity Data Power control, actuators Power supply Sensing processing and storage Enabling Devices, Technologies, Architectures Nanoscale FET Power devices Computing paradigms System Design MEMS Emerging devices Heterogeneous Integration Connectivity Manufacturing Science Equipment and Materials 10

Format of the preliminary Roadmap Application requirements Long term: Medium term: Performance of function or technology, or novel functionality Performance of function or technology, or novel functionality Short term Gaps Convergence Other disruptive Applications based on technological evolution Planned Technology evolution based on extrapolation of present SoA at TRLs No Value of technological FoM or novel functionality solution

Objectives NEREID 2nd GW New Application Experts and requirements vs time horizon => Technology Experts can ask A.E. to specify the requirements Analysis of the convergence between Technologies and Applications and main challenges based on the First GW in Grenoble and Domain Workshops for each Task/WP WP/Tasks presentation Application Experts can ask T.E. to add research directions in the Roadmap to develop some additional technologies not taken into account Take into account the new application requirements for the mid-term Roadmap (preliminary analysis) and strengthen the analysis for the final Roadmap Discussants and rapporteurs for each talk

Agenda NEREID 2ndGeneral Workshop DAY1: Thursday April 6th, 2017 Session1 8:30 13:00 New Applications experts or new presentations 8:30 8:45 Introduction (F. Balestra) 8:45 9:25 Orange for Nanotechnologies: an opportunity for green networks: Thomas Rivera 9:25 10:05 SCHNEIDER Electric for Energy: Miao-Xin Wang 10:05 10:45 IMEC for Health: Maaike Op de Beeck 10:45 11:05 Coffee Break 11:05 11:45 Bosh for Automotive: Christian Silber 11:45 12:25 GEMALTO for Security: Jean-Pierre Tual 12:25 13:00 SINTEF for IoT: Ovidiu Vermesan 13:00 14:00 Lunch Session2 14:00 18:00 Feedback from the Domain Workshops by Tasks & WP leaders Interactions with Application experts Discussions 14:00 14:15 Introduction (E. Sangiorgi) 14:15 14:55 Domain workshop Nanoscale FET (Task 3.1) Francis Balestra 14:55 15:35 Domain workshop Connectivity (Task 3.2) Didier Belot 15:35 16:15 Domain workshop Smart Energy (Task 4.2) Wolfgang Dettmann/Gaudenzio Meneghesso 16:15 16:40 Coffee break 16:40 17:20 Domain workshop Energy for Autonomous system (Sub TaskT4.2) Gustavo Ardila 17:20 18:00 Domain workshop Smart Sensors (Task 4.1) Montserrat Fernandez-Bolanos 19:00 Cocktail Dinner 13

Agenda NEREID 2ndGeneral Workshop DAY2: Friday April 7th, 2017 Steering Committee meeting: 8:00-9:00 Session3 9:00 12:10 Feedback from the Domain Workshops by Tasks & WP leaders Interactions with Application experts Discussions 9:00 9:15 Introduction (E. Sangiorgi) 9:15 9:55 Domain workshop WP2 Beyond CMOS Emerging devices (Task 2.1) ( Jouni Ahopelto / Clivia Sotomayor- Torres) 9:55 10:35 Domain workshop System Design (Task 5.1) Danilo DeMarchi 10:35 10:50 Coffee Break 10:50 11:30 Domain workshop Heterogeneous Integration (Task 5.2) Georgios Fagas 11:30 12:10 Domain workshop WP6 Equipment & Manufacturing Science Markus Pfeffer 12:10-13:00 Lunch Session4 13:00 15:30 IRDS Presentations - Conclusions and next steps (F. Balestra) 2 Presentations of IRDS (2* 20 mn): Paolo Gargini and Mustafa Badaroglu Convergence Technologies Applications Draft of preliminary Roadmap Next steps 15:30 16:30 Coffee Break Advisory Board meeting: 17:00-19:30 Joint AB Dinner: 20:15 14

Next Steps Advisory Board, April 7, 2017, Athens M18 (May 2017): mid-term Roadmap 2nd Review Meeting, June 2017 Organization of 2nd Sessions of Domain/Cross-Domain Workshops in all the Tasks/WPs Interaction with IRDS Organization of the 3rd General Workshop (2018) M36 (Nov. 2018): final Roadmap

A fruitful collaboration will be strengthened in NEREID during 3 years! Thank you ! Contact : francis.balestra@grenoble-inp.fr

Convergence Technologies-Applications First part of NEREID (M0-M18): Analysis of the Convergence between Technologies and Applications based on the First GW in Grenoble and 1st Session of Domain Workshops => presented in Sessions 2-3 during GW2 2nd GW: New Application Experts and requirements => Take into account the new application requirements for the mid-term Roadmap (preliminary analysis) and strengthen the analysis for the final Roadmap

Mid-term Roadmap Proposed structure of the roadmap I. General Introduction (main objectives of NEREID roadmap) II. Roadmapping Process III.Application domains IV.Interactions with other international activities V. Workpackage chapters considering all tasks: WP2-6 VI.General recommendations VII.Final recommendations and continuous activities VIII. General Conclusion

Mid-term Roadmap (2) V. WP Chapters: 1. Executive summary 2. Relevance 2.1 Competitive value 2.2 Societal benefits 3. Vision (of the WP topic) 4. Scope and ambition (of the WP topic) 5. Main Concepts (see next slide)

Mid-term Roadmap (3) Medium term: 5+ Long term: 10+ i i) Concept n ) Concept n a) Key research questions or issues b) Potential for application or Application needs and Impact for Europe c) Technology and design challenges d) Definition of FoMs (quantative or qualitative) or planned evolution (based on SoA @ 2017 and evolution vs time) . e) Other issues and challenges, and interaction with other Tasks/WPs. 5.n.1 Competitive situation (of concept n) 5.n.2 Recommendations (on Concept n)

Next Steps Advisory Board, April 7, 2017, Athens M18 (May 2017): mid-term Roadmap 2nd Review Meeting, June 2017 Organization of 2nd Sessions of Domain/Cross-Domain Workshops in all the Tasks/WPs Strengthen interaction with IRDS for the final Roadmap Organization of the 3rd General Workshop (2018) M36 (Nov. 2018): final Roadmap